The Music Man at Goodspeed Is a Tuneful Delight for Audiences of All Ages

Posted by
The Music Man
Photo by Diane Sobolewski

By Karen Isaacs

 If there is trouble on the Goodspeed stage, is is only the new pool table in River City, Iowa and  it is the very best kind of trouble. The type of trouble that exhilarates and enchants. The Music Man which is opening the Goodspeed season through Thursday, June 20 is a sheer delight.

The credit can be shared among many of the production team led by director Jenn Thompson, but a large part of the credit must go to Edward Watts who is outstanding as Professor Harold Hill.

It’s amazing that this classic musical by Meredith Willson is having its first production at Goodspeed. It seems perfectly suited to the theater.

In case you have forgotten the plot, it is 1912 in River City, Iowa and a traveling salesman/con artist “Professor” Harold Hill arrives in town. His game? Find something new in the town, in this case a pool table in the billiards parlor, and convince the people that the youth of the town are in deep trouble that can only be saved with a boy’s band. Of course, he is going to sell them the instruments and uniforms and teach the boys to play. The first two are true but Hill cannot teach them a note; the plan is to get out of town before anyone figures that out.

In River City he finds his old sidekick Marcellus (now gone straight) who is willing to jump back into the game. He also finds the local piano teacher, this time the quite attractive and young Marian Paroo who is also the town’s librarian. Part of his routine is to woo the local piano teacher.

As in any 1950s musical, we have the teenage couple (he’s from the wrong side of the tracks and she’s the mayor’s daughter) and assorted other folk. The complications include the fact that the Mayor owns the billiards parlor that Hill is attacking.

But as in any musical of the era, all works out in the end.

What set this show apart originally and even today is the terrific score by Willson. While this was his first Broadway musical, he was not only a well-known performer (a classically trained flute player) but a musical director of many 1930s -40s radio shows, the composer of scores for many movies and the hit song “May the Lord Bless and Keep You.”

Willson had a knack for writing interlocking melodies – two different melodies that work perfectly when sung together; he makes good use of this talent throughout the show.

Let’s start with the production elements of the show. Thompson has directed with a sure hand. She makes effective use of the aisle often using them to highlight the interlocking melodies. Her staging of the end of the songs “Pick-a Little, Talk-a-Little” and “Goodnight Ladies” is excellent: the women finish the song in the left aisle and the four members of the Board of Education who discovered they are a barbershop quartet are in the right aisle facing them.

Of course, she uses the aisle for the final entrance of the band. She is ably assisted by the choreography by Patricia Wilcox who incorporates period dance steps into the show.

The set by Paul Tate dePoo III is brilliant. The back wall has a impressionistic look painted on a brick wall. Later the scene at the footbridge is equally attractive. Add to this the lighting Paul Miller and costumes by David Toser and you have a true sense of a small town in the early 20th century. The costumes are so true to the period; and the hats on the ladies are marvelous.

As usual, sound designer Jay Hilton and musical director Michael O’Flaherty have worked together seamlessly to balance the voices and the orchestra.

Watts is the standout as Hill. He brings charm, good looks and a terrific voice to the part. He conveys sincerity and self-awareness of his deceptive attitudes with ease. His is a performance that I would be happy to see again.

Ellie Fishman has a fine soprano voice for the role of Marian originated by the great Barbara Cook, but she doesn’t infuse the role with sufficient spunk. This Marian seems a trifle bland. She is overshadowed by the Mayor’s wife, Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn played beautifully by Stephanie Pope.

Other standouts in the cast are Alexander O’Brien who plays Marian’s younger brother; he avoids being overly “cute” which so often befalls child actors in this part. D. A. Anderson is fine as Mayor Shinn and Juson Williams is very good as Marcellus.

As the teenager lovers, Shawn Alynda Fisher is good as the silly Zaneeta and Raynor Rubel is excellent as Tommy.

At the heart of The Music Man are the songs and the staging of them. From the opening number “Rock Island” better known as “But he doesn’t know the territory” right through to “Till There Was You” the music is beautifully presented. The show has too many wonderful songs to mention them all – from “Goodnight, My Someone” to “Seventy-Six Trombones” to “Marian the Librarian” to “The Wells Fargo Wagon” to the interlocking “Lida Rose’/ “Will I Ever Tell You?”

You will leave the theater humming and in a very happy place.

Get to see The Music Man – tickets will go quickly. For tickets visit Goodspeed or call 860-873-8668.

This content is courtesy of Shore Publications and

The Music Man
Photo by Diane Sobolewski

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s